. Bulletin of the Museum of Comparative Zoology at Harvard College. Zoology; Zoology. 86 BULLETIN: MUSEUM OF COMPARATIVE ZOOLOGY. designated. It is a well-established principle of nomenclature that in cases like this, or as between names the equal pertinency of which may be in question, " preference shall be given to that which is open to least doubt " (A. O. U. Code, Canon XVII.). As a matter of fact, when these two "species" were united by St. John and Worthen in 1883, some slight doubt was expressed as to their identity, and the authors very properly chose for their comm
. Bulletin of the Museum of Comparative Zoology at Harvard College. Zoology; Zoology. 86 BULLETIN: MUSEUM OF COMPARATIVE ZOOLOGY. designated. It is a well-established principle of nomenclature that in cases like this, or as between names the equal pertinency of which may be in question, " preference shall be given to that which is open to least doubt " (A. O. U. Code, Canon XVII.). As a matter of fact, when these two "species" were united by St. John and Worthen in 1883, some slight doubt was expressed as to their identity, and the authors very properly chose for their common designation that which was founded on the most perfect specimen, and hence was open to least doubt, namely, C. gracillimus. By this decision the spine figured in Plate XIII. Figure 3 of the Illinois Palaeon- tology, Vol. II., was definitely established as the type-specimen, and the only question is whether it actually belongs to Ctenacanthus, or should be removed to Acondylacarithus as was proposed by Newberry in 1889. The latter author rests his claim upon a worn, im- mature, and distorted specimen, now in the Museum of Columbia University, and very much inferior in point of preservation to the spine figured by St. John and Worthen in Vol. II. of the Illinois Palaeontology, to which no reference is made by Newberry. The correctness of St. John and Worthen's deter- mination is confirmed by several additional specimens which have come under the writer's observation, all of which show tuberculated costse, and the absence Ctenacanthus gracil- of this character in Newberry's spine is probably due limus N. & W. St. ^Q abrasion. One example in particular, from the Fig. 12. Louis Limestone; Missouri. Portion of ornamentation. Louis limestone, and belonging to the Museum of Comparative Zoology, exhibits the finer ornamenta- tion very distinctly in its proximal portion (cf. text- figure 12) where the tubercles are seen to be small, stellated, and rather widely spaced in prop
Size: 1448px × 1726px
Photo credit: © Book Worm / Alamy / Afripics
License: Licensed
Model Released: No
Keywords: ., bookauthorha, bookcentury1800, bookdecade1860, booksubjectzoology
